Sandwich Philosophy

The BestSandwich

What actually makes a sandwich the best? After 50+ years and thousands of subs, we have a pretty strong opinion — and it all comes down to a few unbreakable rules.

People argue about sandwiches the way they argue about pizza or barbecue — with total conviction and zero objectivity. Fair enough. But after more than fifty years of building subs on Louisiana Ave in Brooklyn and now here in Phoenix, we've arrived at some pretty firm conclusions about what separates a great sandwich from a truly unforgettable one.

The answer isn't one thing. It's a system. Every element has to earn its place. When they all work together, something almost magical happens — the kind of bite you think about for the rest of the afternoon. Here's what that system looks like.

1. The Bread Has to Be Alive

This is where most sandwiches fail before they begin. Bread that sat in a delivery truck, then a storeroom, then on a shelf — it's already dead. It can't hold up to a generous filling, and it can't give you that crackle-and-chew that makes the whole thing sing.

We bake our rolls fresh every morning. By the time the first customer walks in, the bread is still at its peak: a crust that yields with just the right resistance, a crumb that's soft and airy but sturdy enough to carry everything we pile on. That's the foundation. Everything else rests on it.

2. Quality Meats — No Compromises, Ever

The family recipe that Mike brought from Brooklyn in 1968 wasn't written down. It lived in instinct — in knowing exactly which meats were worth serving and which weren't. That instinct has never changed.

We hand-slice our deli meats because pre-packaged, pre-sliced product has already lost something. The texture is different. The flavor is flatter. Our cuts are thicker where they should be thick, thinner where the layering calls for it. Whether it's pastrami, turkey, or a classic Italian spread, every protein on the board was chosen because it's simply the best version of itself we could find.

3. Vegetables That Were Alive This Morning

A tomato that's been sitting pre-cut in a container since yesterday morning is a different ingredient than one that was sliced an hour ago. The water content changes. The cell structure softens. It stops tasting like a tomato and starts tasting like the memory of one.

We cut our vegetables every day. It's not complicated — it's just a commitment to doing things right. Crisp lettuce. Tomatoes with real acidity. Onions with actual bite. Peppers that snap. These aren't garnishes; they're load-bearing members of the sandwich.

4. Balance — The Thing You Can't Fake

The best sandwich isn't about any single ingredient overpowering the rest. It's about proportion and balance — the ratio of meat to bread, the placement of vegetables so they don't all fall out in the first bite, the right amount of oil and seasoning so the flavors deepen without drowning each other.

This is where craft comes in. After decades of building subs, the people behind our counter have an intuitive sense for it. It's not a formula. It's a feel. And it's the hardest thing to teach — which is why it's the thing we're most proud of.

5. It Has to Be Made by Someone Who Cares

This one sounds like a cliché, but it's the most important rule on the list. The best sandwich is made by someone who actually gives a damn — who notices when the bread could be slightly better, who takes the extra second to fold the meat properly, who thinks of the finished product as something worth being proud of.

Brooklyn Mike's has always been a family operation. Mike's family carried these standards from Brooklyn to Phoenix, and those standards are still alive in the shop every single day. When you eat here, you're eating something made with genuine pride — not by a machine optimized for speed, but by people who have chosen this craft as their life's work.

"The best sandwich isn't the fanciest one. It's the one made right."

— Brooklyn Mike's, since 1968

Come See What We Mean

All of this is well and good to read. But the best way to understand what we're talking about is to come in and taste it. Our doors are open from 2pm to 5pm every day. Order the Italian — or if you already have a favorite, order that. Either way, we think you'll understand within the first bite why this family has been doing things exactly this way for over fifty years.

Ready to try the best sandwich in Phoenix?

Open 2pm–5pm every day. Come hungry.

More from the kitchen

← All Posts